Texas Ballot Compare

General election · Tuesday, November 3, 2026

Nonpartisan voter guide · Texas

Judge, Court of Criminal Appeals, Place 9

Race · November 3, 2026 general election

State of Texas
Vote for oneResearched · fact-checked
John MessingerRepublican
Holly TaylorHolly TaylorDemocratic
On ballot as
JOHN MESSINGER
HOLLY TAYLOR
Current role
Assistant State Prosecuting Attorney
Principal attorney, Holly Taylor Law
Background
  • B.S. and M.S. in Business,
  • Baylor Law School
  • B.A., Rice University
  • Law degree and Master of Public Affairs, University of Texas
  • Board certified in criminal appellate law
Experience
  • Appellate prosecutor, McLennan County District Attorney's Office;
  • Office of the State Prosecuting Attorney
  • Over 17 years as a Travis County prosecutor,
  • Staff attorney and Rules Attorney, Court of Criminal Appeals.
Top priorities
  • "Justice Through Law Enforcement": "enforcing the laws as written to find out what works and what doesn't"
  • Says the court's average time to review a lower court decision "increased to over 500 days"
  • Says many recent court opinions "ignore or conflict with applicable law, its own decisions, or both"
  • "Bring an independent voice to the Court of Criminal Appeals to ensure that cases receive a fair and thorough review"
  • Decisions "grounded in the Constitution and the Rule of Law"
  • "Treating everyone with dignity and humanity"
Tidbits
  • Judicial philosophy: Campaign site: says improving the justice system comes from "enforcing the laws as written", not from "judges doing whatever they think is right in their own eyes"
Research pending
Endorsements
  • True Texas Project
  • Young Conservatives of Texas
  • Houston Police Officers' Union
  • Texas Home School Coalition
  • Numerous Republican Officials and Conservative Organizations – too many to list (see website)
  • Texas AFL-CIO COPE
  • Numerous Democrat Officials and Liberal Organizations – too many to list (see website)
  • Houston LGBTQ+ Political Caucus

John Messinger

Republican
On ballot as
JOHN MESSINGER
Current role
Assistant State Prosecuting Attorney
Background
  • B.S. and M.S. in Business,
  • Baylor Law School
Experience
  • Appellate prosecutor, McLennan County District Attorney's Office;
  • Office of the State Prosecuting Attorney
Top priorities
  • "Justice Through Law Enforcement": "enforcing the laws as written to find out what works and what doesn't"
  • Says the court's average time to review a lower court decision "increased to over 500 days"
  • Says many recent court opinions "ignore or conflict with applicable law, its own decisions, or both"
Tidbits
  • Judicial philosophy: Campaign site: says improving the justice system comes from "enforcing the laws as written", not from "judges doing whatever they think is right in their own eyes"
Endorsements
  • True Texas Project
  • Young Conservatives of Texas
  • Houston Police Officers' Union
  • Texas Home School Coalition
  • Numerous Republican Officials and Conservative Organizations – too many to list (see website)
Campaign website
messingerforjustice.com
Holly Taylor

Holly Taylor

Democratic
On ballot as
HOLLY TAYLOR
Current role
Principal attorney, Holly Taylor Law
Background
  • B.A., Rice University
  • Law degree and Master of Public Affairs, University of Texas
  • Board certified in criminal appellate law
Experience
  • Over 17 years as a Travis County prosecutor,
  • Staff attorney and Rules Attorney, Court of Criminal Appeals.
Top priorities
  • "Bring an independent voice to the Court of Criminal Appeals to ensure that cases receive a fair and thorough review"
  • Decisions "grounded in the Constitution and the Rule of Law"
  • "Treating everyone with dignity and humanity"
Tidbits
Research pending
Endorsements
  • Texas AFL-CIO COPE
  • Numerous Democrat Officials and Liberal Organizations – too many to list (see website)
  • Houston LGBTQ+ Political Caucus
Campaign website
hollytforjudge.com