Texas Ballot Compare

General election · Tuesday, November 3, 2026

Nonpartisan voter guide · Texas

Justice, 1st Court of Appeals District, Place 5

Race · November 3, 2026 general election

State of Texas
Vote for oneResearched · fact-checked
Jessica CairdJessica CairdRepublican
Amy GuerraAmy GuerraDemocratic Incumbent
On ballot as
JESSICA CAIRD
AMY GUERRA
Current role
Assistant District Attorney, Harris County District Attorney's Office
Justice, First Court of Appeals, Place 5 (elected 2020; in office since January 1, 2021)
Background
  • B.A. in English Literature, American University
  • J.D., University of Houston Law Center
  • B.A., Rice University (Latin American Studies and Sociology)
  • J.D., University of Houston Law Center
  • Former law clerk, U.S. District Judge Filemón Vela
  • Daughter of Retired Senior Justice Linda Yáñez
Experience
  • Appellate Division Chief (since 2021) (per campaign)
  • Assistant District Attorney, Harris County, 26 years (per campaign)
  • Appellate attorney, nearly 19 years (per campaign)
  • Over 41 jury trials tried (per campaign)
  • Over 440 briefs filed (per campaign)
  • 34 oral arguments (per campaign)
  • Nearly 20 years handling complex civil cases
  • First Hispanic partner at her law firm
  • Associate Municipal Judge, City of Houston (first appointed 2005)
Top priorities
  • "the job of a judge is not to ignore or create the law, but to faithfully apply it as written" (per campaign)
  • U.S. and Texas Constitutions "must be interpreted as written because they stand as the will of the people" (per campaign)
  • "committed to public safety, protecting your rights, and upholding the rule of law" (per campaign)
Tidbits
  • Judicial philosophy: Her campaign site says "the job of a judge is not to ignore or create the law, but to faithfully apply it as written by the Texas Legislature and as enshrined in the Constitution"
  • Court administration: No public statement found
  • Judicial philosophy: Her campaign site says she "is committed to public safety, protecting your rights, and upholding the rule of law"
  • Court administration: No public statement found
Endorsements
  • Houston Police Officers' Union (shared endorsement)
  • Texas Gulf Coast Area Labor Federation
  • Houston Association of Women Attorneys
  • Houston LGBTQ+ Political Caucus
  • Bay Area Democratic Movement
  • Houston Police Officers' Union (shared endorsement)
Jessica Caird

Jessica Caird

Republican
On ballot as
JESSICA CAIRD
Current role
Assistant District Attorney, Harris County District Attorney's Office
Background
  • B.A. in English Literature, American University
  • J.D., University of Houston Law Center
Experience
  • Appellate Division Chief (since 2021) (per campaign)
  • Assistant District Attorney, Harris County, 26 years (per campaign)
  • Appellate attorney, nearly 19 years (per campaign)
  • Over 41 jury trials tried (per campaign)
  • Over 440 briefs filed (per campaign)
  • 34 oral arguments (per campaign)
Top priorities
  • "the job of a judge is not to ignore or create the law, but to faithfully apply it as written" (per campaign)
  • U.S. and Texas Constitutions "must be interpreted as written because they stand as the will of the people" (per campaign)
Tidbits
  • Judicial philosophy: Her campaign site says "the job of a judge is not to ignore or create the law, but to faithfully apply it as written by the Texas Legislature and as enshrined in the Constitution"
  • Court administration: No public statement found
Endorsements
  • Houston Police Officers' Union (shared endorsement)
Campaign website
cairdforjustice.com
Amy Guerra

Amy Guerra

Democratic Incumbent
On ballot as
AMY GUERRA
Current role
Justice, First Court of Appeals, Place 5 (elected 2020; in office since January 1, 2021)
Background
  • B.A., Rice University (Latin American Studies and Sociology)
  • J.D., University of Houston Law Center
  • Former law clerk, U.S. District Judge Filemón Vela
  • Daughter of Retired Senior Justice Linda Yáñez
Experience
  • Nearly 20 years handling complex civil cases
  • First Hispanic partner at her law firm
  • Associate Municipal Judge, City of Houston (first appointed 2005)
Top priorities
  • "committed to public safety, protecting your rights, and upholding the rule of law" (per campaign)
Tidbits
  • Judicial philosophy: Her campaign site says she "is committed to public safety, protecting your rights, and upholding the rule of law"
  • Court administration: No public statement found
Endorsements
  • Texas Gulf Coast Area Labor Federation
  • Houston Association of Women Attorneys
  • Houston LGBTQ+ Political Caucus
  • Bay Area Democratic Movement
  • Houston Police Officers' Union (shared endorsement)
Campaign website
justiceguerra.com